How to plan a murder mystery header

Host the Ultimate Murder Mystery Game Night for Large Groups

A personalized murder mystery game for 12 to 200+ guests

Make My Murder Mystery Game

Planning an event needn't be murder

Our personalized murder mystery game maker makes it easy plan a whodunnit event your guests will never forget.


Personalize your murder mystery party

Get creative and have fun with the script


For 12 to 200+ Guests

Play virtually or in real life


Simple to make. Easy to play

Fun and safe for all murderers aged 11+

Create your personalized murder mystery game for large groups

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly
  • Play online or in-person
Make My Murder Mystery Game

Tired of the same old game nights with family or friends? Ready to take your next game night to the next level? Look no further - hosting a Murder Mystery game night is exactly what your large group needs! Get your closest pals, family, coworkers, and whoever else you want to invite - this exciting night involves plenty of fun clue-seeking to discover who dunnit - and you'll have the perfect setup. We'll provide you with all the tools you need to get your mystery night up and running, so all that's left for you to do is invite your guests, and get ready for a wild ride! Let's find out how you can host the ultimate murder mystery game night for large groups.

Quick Insight

Clue and Mysterium are both excellent choices for large groups. These games use deduction and problem-solving skills, making them great for bigger groups of people.

The Components of A Murder Mystery Game

Murder mystery games are a fun and engaging way to bring large groups together. Hosting the ultimate murder mystery game night requires a bit of thought and organization, starting with selecting game components. There are two primary components that make up a murder mystery game: the script, which includes various roles for players, and the props, which provide clues and help deepen the story. It's important to take stock of these two items when planning your game night.

When it comes to choosing scripts for your murder mystery game, you have options. Some popular choices include pre-written scenarios complete with characters and props. Played like an interactive dinner theater, these game nights are sure to be exciting as each player is assigned a role and guided through the story as it unfolds. On the other hand, some may prefer a more open-ended approach such as creating their own script in advance or allowing players to make up their own roles as they go. This option offers more spontaneity and creativity but may require a bit more planning on your part.

Props can range from items specifically designed for murder mystery games such as clue cards and puzzles or everyday objects like playing cards or photos. While you don't need to get too elaborate when it comes to props, incorporating meaningful items into the story can help give it depth and realism. Some pre-made sets come with great props already included while others let you create your own pieces—allowing for endless customization possibilities.

No matter which route you decide to take for your murder mystery game night, having a combination of both scripts and props will ensure an entertaining evening for all involved. Now that we know the components of a murder mystery game, let's explore how we can select the theme and suspect next!

Key Points to Know

Murder mystery games are a fun and engaging way to bring large groups together. Hosting an ultimate murder mystery game night includes components such as a script, which contains roles for players, and props, which provide clues. There are various options for scripts, such as pre-written scenarios or creating your own. Props can range from items specifically designed for murder mysteries or everyday objects. Having both a script and props is necessary for an entertaining evening.

Selecting the Theme and the Suspect

Selecting the theme and suspect of a murder mystery game is an important step in hosting the ultimate game night. There are generally two approaches to this task: either create a custom game with a personalized theme and suspect or purchase an existing game.

Creating a custom game can be incredibly rewarding! It allows you to craft the theme and backstory around your group's interests, making it more enjoyable and interesting. Moreover, it gives your group ultimate flexibility in terms of length, complexity, style and scope of the game. The only disadvantage is that it requires significant preparation time in order to craft the storyline, assemble props and puzzles, develop characters, design invitations and plan out all subsequent steps.

On the other hand, purchasing a pre-made mystery game may be ideal for those who do not have much time available for preparations. Pre-assembled games are hassle-free as they come with everything you need from full story outlines to character profiles and clues. What’s more, lots of existing kits help to set you up for success without having strains on your wallet by providing detailed rulebooks and even hosting materials down to props like fake objects. The downside of using pre-made kits is that you may not find one that suits your preferences in terms of difficulty level or creativity.

After selecting the theme of your game night and determining whether or not you will build a custom mystery or use a pre-made kit, the next step is to choose your suspect. Many hosts opt to pick a personified character alluding to their guests’ interests as viewers are less able to solve the crime if they cannot relate to the victim or have any investment into solving it. It may also seem more realistic when there is a tangible villain. The murderer should also present enough motive that people can comprehend why they have committed the crime - but not too blatantly obvious where people can pinpoint who it is right away!

Now that you have chosen a theme and suspect for your ultimate murder mystery game night for large groups, it is time to prepare the clues!

Preparing the Clues

Creating a great puzzle is a surefire way to ensure an unforgettable murder mystery game night for large groups. Though it can seem intimidating at first, with a little bit of planning and preparation, you can have all your clues ready in no time.

To begin, you’ll need to decide what type of clue you want to give players—physical evidence that requires observation and detective work or more abstract clues involving psychological challenges. The choice will depend on the type of game you’ve chosen and the number of players, but either option is sure to keep your guests engaged.

For physical clues, think about what objects might be connected to the suspects or how they could all relate back to the crime scene. You can get creative with things like paper papers and puzzles or use something more traditional like hidden messages or strange objects. For example, you could use clothing scraps, pieces of a suspect’s phone, fingerprint records or receipts as evidence. Once the evidence has been collected by players and correctly identified, they can be used to figure out who committed the mysterious act.

However, if you’re looking for something a bit more abstract, consider giving clues that involve psychological activities such as code-breaking or riddles related to the suspects’ behavior and intentions. These types of clues take quite some thought and problem-solving skills but can be quite interesting as well!

Whichever type of clue you choose for your murder mystery game night for large groups, make sure it poses enough difficulty for your guests to stay entertained yet not too difficult that they feel hopelessly stumped. After all, it's important that they still have fun!

Now that you’ve prepared your clues and everyone is ready to go, it's time to set up the scene!

Setting Up the Scene

Setting up the scene for a murder mystery game night is one of the most crucial steps to ensure your guests have an enjoyable and successful experience. To create an atmosphere of intrigue, it is important to do more than just provide clues and a plot summary. Careful consideration should be taken when deciding on a physical environment or backdrop for your game night.

One approach to designing the environment is to re-create certain elements from the mystery itself. Props, decorations, and costumes can be used to bring characters and plot points to life for guests. This allows for players to be more engaged in the mystery as they feel more immersed in the role-playing action. Additionally, crafting custom clues tied to the props or setting will further add to the authenticity of being part of solving a puzzle.

On the other hand, not all mysteries require such attention to detail with regards to setting. If the mystery is more focused on guessing the culprit or hacking through abstract clues rather than feeling like they are physically inside a different space or time period, then decoration might not be necessary at all. Depending on how complex you want your game night atmosphere to be, you could always adjust accordingly without sacrificing too much enjoyment from your guests.

Now that you have your scene set up for ultimate murder mystery game night for large groups, it is time to explore how best to create props that will further engage your guests and serve as concrete pieces towards solving the case.

Creating the Props

When strategizing how to create a successful murder mystery game, props are a key element. Props can help create an interactive and engaging atmosphere for the guests. To host the ultimate murder mystery game night for large groups, it’s important for the props to be realistic and of high quality. Creating believable props will make guests feel more involved in the story during gameplay.

On one hand, investing in expensive, high-quality props may offer a more professional quality and immersive atmosphere. Stylish replicas of guns or other objects used in the game can add a sense of creative storytelling when portraying characters and scenes. On the other hand, it is possible to make your own props with a lower cost but still enough realistic effect. Investing in raw materials such as foam boards and spray paints are often cheaper than buying pre-made props and can also give you more room to create what is needed for the specific game at hand.

Whichever approach you decide to take when making the props, planning ahead is essential. Many prepackaged murder mysteries will require certain accessories that you’ll need to acquire before hosting the game night—from magnifying glasses to notebooks filled with clues. Taking advantage of craft stores and online retailers can help curate pieces that make sense for your game narrative as well as stick within your theme or budget parameters.

Now that you have crafted your perfect props, it's time to design an exciting murder mystery game for your large group!

Designing an Exciting Murder Mystery Game

Designing an Exciting Murder Mystery Game can be both exciting and challenging. Deciding the theme of the game, where it will take place, who will play, and all the details that go into creating this party can seem daunting task. Allowing for ample amount of planning time is essential for pulling off a great event and ensuring that guests have an enjoyable experience.

First and foremost, do some research to choose the best type of murder mystery game for the event. There are options to buy a pre-developed murder mystery game or make your own from scratch. Commercial mystery games come with a script, detailed instructions on how to set up the night, character invitations, and all sorts of props. While a store-bought mystery may be easier to prepare, customizing your own will allow you to better tailor it to the size and interests of your group.

Creating a successful murder mystery game consists of more than just writing the story - decisions must also be made on the number of characters and their roles; setting the scene; providing clues; designing engaging tasks; crafting clues that point in the right direction without giving away too much too quickly; devising puzzles; and finally, splitting up players into teams as needed or having them work together as one large group. Being well organized with your materials and timing is crucial to leading a successful game so each clue leads logically from one to the next

Finally, casting savvy participants is essential for making any murder mystery come alive. Having key players integrate their characters into conversations throughout with appropriate responses not only brings entertainment but provides the opportunity for other participants to interact as well.

Designing an Exciting Murder Mystery Game is no small feat but can be achieved with adequate preparation. The next step for creating an unforgettable experience is assigning players to their roles - a task which has its own unique set of challenges that must be met in order to ensure a successful game night.

  • According to a survey conducted in 2020, 63% of people believe that playing an interactive murder mystery game is more fun than watching a movie or TV show.
  • A recent study found that murder mysteries can help strengthen social bonds within teams since it requires different players to work together to solve a common problem.
  • Research indicates that 78% of people enjoy playing mystery games as individuals and 80% find them even more fun when playing with friends.

Assigning the Participants their Roles

A key part of hosting a successful murder mystery game night is assigning the participants their roles. Some game hosts prefer to assign roles in advance, while others prefer to allow players to select their own. Both methods have advantages and disadvantages.

Advantages of assigning roles in advance include: allowing for more thorough storyline planning, introducing suspense ahead of time to further motivate participants, and allowing the host to tailor roles to each participant. This method can also facilitate a smoother flow at game night since all participants will already be familiar with their characters.

The main disadvantage of assigning roles in advance is that it doesn’t give participants much freedom to decide how they want to portray their character. Additionally, if there are too many variables or unknowns, it can be difficult or even impossible for the host to accurately plan out roles in advance.

Alternatively, allowing players to decide their roles has its advantages as well. This increases the suspense and intrigue of game night and allows players more creative control over how they choose to interpret their characters. However, assigning roles on the night itself can take away from the allotted playtime and make it harder for the host to identify synergies between different characters ahead of time.

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to pre-assign roles is up the game host’s discretion – but either way, making sure that everyone can clearly distinguish between characters is a crucial part of creating a successful murder mystery evening.

To ensure maximum engagement and suspense at your murder mystery game night, it is important for hosts to learn how to make the game more difficult. The next section discusses several strategies for doing this.

How to Make the Game More Difficult

Making the game more difficult is essential for keeping large groups entertained. It can be done in a variety of ways and will depend on the group's preferences as well. For example, some players may appreciate a simplified game with fewer suspects, while others may want one that is more complex with puzzles and multiple stages.

One way to challenge an audience is by making it more competitive. This can be achieved by adding players who are “mafia” or outsiders to the game. These players have a secret knowledge that they must use to their advantage to disguise themselves from the other players. By having mafia members thrown into the mix, it adds depth and complexity that encourages players to think more strategically about changing circumstances. Alternatively, establish a point system for each participant and reward those who reveal the right answers quickly.

If the group already enjoys a competitive setting, another way to up the difficulty is by adding clues into the mix. Clues are important and unique pieces of information discoverable by players throughout the game. Each clue should serve some kind of purpose–foreshadowing a character’s identity or introducing an important narrative development in-game–and should be distributed evenly amongst all participating teams, forcing every team to investigate incessantly in order to surmount their peers. Of course, clues must not only be spread throughout during gameplay but also hidden in plain sight–this allows competitors participating in the game enough time to analyze the situation without getting off too easy or too hard compared to others who possess relevant intelligence about key plot points ahead of time.

Finally, lengthen out timeline of the game and make sure that you have plenty of twists and turns embedded within it. This will give your audience even more opportunities to apply their detective skills and theorize about what could transpire next as mysteries unfold before them over longer periods of time; thus making it increasingly hard for them to predict what might happen along with adding suspense into the mix.

With all these methods discussed, we can see how much potential there is for making any murder mystery game night incredibly immersive and thrilling regardless of age-level or size of group attending. Now let’s take some time dissect how key elements such as rules of play fit into analyzing a game’s outcome during in the next section. Analyzing the Game Play...

Analyzing the Game Play

As the game play of a murder mystery night progresses, it’s important to be able to assess how the evening is progressing in order for it to be successful for all involved. When analyzing the game play, factors such as pacing, difficulty level of the content and interaction between participants should be considered.

When analyzing the pacing of the game, you can ensure that your guest don’t become bored or frustrated by giving them clues or tasks at an appropriate rate. Different groups have different energy levels, so you can tailor the pacing to suit accordingly. Additionally, if any puzzles or tasks seem too difficult, consider whether there are any alternative activities you could provide to help participants progress.

On the other hand, if content appears to be too easy then look at ways to make it more interesting or challenging. This could include providing extra puzzle pieces as optional challenges for experienced players. Alternatively, this could mean considering side missions for more active players who want some extra thrill during game play – just make sure you don’t put too much on their plate!

Observing the interactions between participants is also a key factor in assessing how your murder mystery night is going. As guests mingle and work together try to observe how everyone is getting on and if anyone needs support or guidance with certain tasks. Additionally, encouraging conversations among guests is always beneficial – having guests take turns in asking each other questions related to the murder mystery theme can help break down any awkwardness while giving them information they need to piece together what happened that fateful night.

These are a few important elements when assessing how your large group murder mystery night is progressing. Now let's move onto alternatives to murder mystery games that could help create an even more memorable evening…

Alternatives to Murder Mystery Games

When it comes to hosting a large group game night, it's important to have a variety of activities on hand. Though murder mystery games can be fun, especially for whodunit enthusiasts, there are plenty of alternatives available that may prove even more entertaining.

Escape Rooms: Escape rooms are physical experiences in which players solve puzzles and tasks while trying to "escape" within a certain period of time. Many escape room options are now available online, either in real-time or pre-recorded versions. This can make it easier for participants who live long distances from each other.

Alternate Board Games: With so many offbeat board games out there these days, hosting an adult game night is easy! Some crowd favorites include The Voting Game, Scrawl - the Dirtiest Drawing Party Game, Never Have I Ever, You've Got Crabs!, Skribblio and many more.

Video Gaming: Video games provide endless hours of entertainment and can sometimes bridge gaps among players who wouldn't normally interact with each other. Popular streaming apps such as Twitch and YouTube Gaming make it possible for those who aren't in the same room together to connect through their love of gaming. All you need is a good internet connection and some competitive spirit.

Live Action Role Playing Games (LARPs): Large groups can also become immersed in imaginative storylines through live action role playing (LARPing). Participants will get to create their own characters based on the given scenario, which often contributes to group dynamics and creative problem solving. LARPing unite people regardless of background, age or personality and can make for an enjoyable game night experience.

Hybrid Experiences: Finally, hybrid experiences combine elements from various activities to create something totally unique. An example could be an escape room/murder mystery adventure where gamers must solve clues to figure out who committed the crime before time runs out! By combining different elements from traditional activities as well as emerging technologies like virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR), hosts can create exciting new opportunities for guests to interact with one another.

Overall, there’s no denying the appeal of murder mystery games when throwing a large group game night. However, with so many stimulating alternatives available nowadays, no evening with friends or family has to follow a predictable pattern or enjoy limited choices - making it easy to host the ultimate game night experience!

Common Questions and Explanations

What are some examples of murder mystery games suitable for large groups?

When it comes to murder mystery games suitable for large groups, there are many great options available. Some popular examples include “Clue”, “Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective”, “Murder by the Book”, and “Where There's a Will”. Each of these games can accommodate up to 10 players in teams or individually.

In “Clue”, players must work together to discover who the murderer is, which weapon was used, and where the crime took place by asking questions and carefully considering each other's answers. This classic game provides group members with plenty of involvement and everyone gets a chance to win.

“Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective” involves up to 8 players joining forces to solve a case together by reviewing evidence and interviewing suspects around Victorian London. It's great for those who enjoy puzzles and deduction.

In “Murder by the Book”, everyone gets their own unique role in an Agatha Christie novel-style plot – perfect for fans of detective fiction. Players must use logic and intuition to figure out who is guilty and take them down before they're able to successfully commit their crime.

Lastly, “Where There's a Will” encourages players to craft alibis for their character that will lead them to victory despite everything that could potentially go wrong with their plan. The game requires creativity on all sides as players race against each other to figure out the devious plots hidden in this exciting story-solving adventure.

How can I adjust a murder mystery game to accommodate a large group?

In order to adjust a murder mystery game to accommodate a large group, it is important to consider both the size of the space and the number of players. If the room is too small for all guests, then consider splitting the group into teams or assigning multiple players a single role. Additionally, additional roles can be added to allow more people to participate and engage in solving the mystery. Adding clues or puzzles that require problem-solving or teamwork can also be effective in engaging large groups. Having a moderator to facilitate conversations and help move things along helps keep everyone focused on the game and prevents any lulls in play if one team is struggling with a clue or puzzle. Finally, it may be beneficial to break out of traditional roles and provide unusual characters like an evil scientist, circus clown, robot or alien to help engage participants more deeply in the mystery.

What is the best way to involve everyone in a large group murder mystery game?

The best way to involve everyone in a large group murder mystery game is to break the large group into smaller ones. Each of the smaller groups can then be given specific tasks and roles in the game so that everyone has a part to play and an individual responsibility. For example, one group can investigate clues, another can act as witnesses, and another can put together the pieces of evidence. This type of setup allows each individual or group to contribute to the larger game and feel involved. Additionally, having a set goal for each smaller team makes the game more competitive, encouraging collaboration and problem solving. Lastly, it’s important to plan out the entire game in advance because larger groups can require more attention to detail and active management to ensure that all participants are engaged throughout.

Create a personalized murder mystery game

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly to your phone
  • Play online or in real life
Build My Personalized Murder Mystery Game

For 200+ Guests

Large group fun

Create your own murder mystery

Personalized game script

Quick and simple to build

Only takes 15 mins to create

Add your own characters

Use real names or make them up

Play on your phone

Or print out the PDF script

Fun for everyone

Detectives aged 11+

Whodunnit game night

A murder mystery game to play with guests

Crime solving game

Use your detective skills

“It was so much fun and easy for people to get involved. A really brilliant murder mystery story!”

Nick T

“Everyone was engaged from the start and threw themselves into solving the murder. The event was great fun – and brilliant value for money.”

Bryn J

“Hilarious! Played over Zoom, in 6 locations, including 2 countries. Even our 78 year old mother managed it!”

Joseph H

“A great night with friends! Will definitely be going with these guys again!”

Tori K

Create your personalized murder mystery game

  • Create a customised murder mystery script in less than 15 mins
  • Perfect for dinner parties and virtual team building
  • Play on screens or print out the PDF scripts
Make My Murder Mystery Game