How to plan a murder mystery header

Host a Murder Mystery Party: Fun Games for Small Groups

Make My Murder Mystery Game

Planning a Zoom party needn't be murder

Our personalized murder mystery game generator makes it easy plan a party your guests will never forget.


Personalize your murder mystery game

Get creative and have fun with the script


Play together

Play virtually or in real life


Simple to set up. Easy to play

Fun and safe for all murderers aged 11+

Create your personalized murder mystery game

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly to your phone
  • Play online or in real life
Build My Personalized Murder Mystery Game

Oh, the alluring mystique of a murder mystery party! From reading Agatha Christie’s classic stories of Poirot, to the night-long games of Clue with family, it is easy to be drawn in to the thought of acting out an unforgettable mystery. Hosting a murder mystery party can be the perfect way to entertain a small group, and these days, it is easier than ever to get the party started. This blog post will show you how to host a murder mystery party with all kinds of fun games that can be tailored to fit any size group. Get ready to start sleuthing!

Quick Summary

Clue and The Werewolf Experiment are both popular murder mystery games that can be played in small groups. There are also various online escape rooms and virtual detective party games available.

What is a Murder Mystery Game?

A murder mystery game is an interactive social game in which the players assume the roles of detectives, trying to solve a faux-murder that has been committed. In most cases, each player is given a character role, complete with a description and background story, from which they should draw information to help them solve the mystery. Typically, one person acts as the criminal and every other player attempts to deduce who the culprit is, based on clues scattered throughout the game.

Murder mystery games can provide an interesting twist to a casual gathering or even a party. On one hand, they can be a great way to engage guests while preserving an air of fun and lightheartedness. On the other hand, some people may find them too complicated or intense for their taste. Those who prefer chill or easygoing activities like board games may not be interested in solving puzzles and interrogating people.

At the same time, if hosted properly and with suitable players, murder mystery games can create exciting memories for participants for years to come. The combination of detective work and critical thinking mixed with deduction skills can make for an invigorating challenge as well as an entertaining group activity.

With that said, it's time to turn our attention to how you can plan a murder mystery game for small groups.

Planning a Murder Mystery Game for Small Groups

Planning a murder mystery game for a small group can be an ideal way to offer a unique and interactive experience for your guests. To get the most out of it, there are lots of consideration that must be taken into account.

The first step is gathering all the necessary pieces needed to create an engaging, memorable experience. This includes writing out a storyline that accurately captures the audience's attention and imagination. Taking the time to write out details such as names, transitions, clues, and climaxes can really bring your game to life. Additionally, purchasing or creating props like weapons, masks, or fake documents will add levels of extra excitement to the game.

Another important consideration is determining how much structure players need in order to make it through the game successfully. Should they receive instruction manuals or simply be given the freedom to investigate? While both have their merits—instruction manuals offering direction whereas freedom allowing creativity—deciding which direction to go in should depend on the goals of each game.

For instance, some games may benefit from having characters with predetermined strengths and weaknesses that require teams to understand their roles well enough in order to succeed. For more improvisational settings where players are allowed more freedom of action and discourse, instructions might not be needed at all. Understanding what type of setting best suits your group will save you a lot of hassle down the line when planning your game.

Now that planning considerations have been discussed, it’s time to move on to how one would gather clues, evidence and characters for such a game. This next section will discuss various methods one can employ while seeking out materials needed for a successful Murder Mystery Party.

Key Takeaways

Planning a murder mystery game requires careful consideration to create an engaging, memorable experience. Writing out detailed storylines and purchasing/creating props are important for bringing the game to life. Additionally, determining the structure of the game should depend on the goals of each game and what best suits your group. The type of clues, evidence and characters used will also play a huge role in creating a successful Murder Mystery Party.

Gather Clues, Evidence, and Characters

Murder mystery parties are entertaining for a small group because they are filled with exciting investigation and solving clues. To have an enjoyable experience, it’s important to gather the clues, evidence, and characters that help make the murder mystery game come to life.

Hosts should give each guest a packet of information about the murder mystery party that includes facts about the characters and evidence associated with the case. This helps guests determine the detective rules for the game and what suspects may have committed the crime. If budget allows, hosts can provide printed materials or leave small trinkets as pieces of evidence at different points in their home or at local venues to bring more excitement to their investigation.

Some guests might prefer to get in character as detectives while others may try to solve the mystery on their own or in teams through costume and acting. Whether guests choose to dress up or not is up to them, but costumes will help set the mood. And contrary to popular belief, hosting a mysterious event doesn’t need expensive costumes—hosts can suggest that guests wear something simple like a trench coat and felt fedora hat to become a detective without breaking the bank.

In addition to providing physical clues, it’s crucial for hosts to plan plot points that lead to specific outcomes as this will help groups piece together bits of evidence from conversations throughout the night. It’s also helpful if hosts create a crime scene setting inside their home so immersive experiences will be maximized.

Now that an understanding of gathering clues, evidence, and characters has been discussed, it's time for hosts to plan a scene and set the mood of their murder mystery party.

Plan a Scene and Set the Mood

When planning a murder mystery party, creating an entertaining scene and setting the mood is essential. A well designed setup can draw people into the storyline and keep them engaged throughout the game. The environment should be conducive to problem solving as well as add to the fun of the story.

When selecting a setting for the mystery, consider how many guests will attend and how much space you need for the activities included in the game. Whether its indoors or outdoors, a comfortable but mysterious atmosphere is key—focus on dimming the lights and playing relaxing music to make attendees feel at ease. Incorporating props, like martini glasses or decorative swords can also help craft the perfect atmosphere. Some people even opt to dress up in costume!

Think carefully about including food and drinks that fit with the theme of your mystery. Small bites should be served without interfering with game play—finger foods are generally easier to manage than large main courses which require time off from solving clues. Beverages should stick to light options such as wine, beer, cocktails or mocktails.

When designing your scene, it's best to have balance between both sombre motifs compatible with the murder theme and vibrant decorations appropriate for a party-like setting. Too many dark elements might put guests in a somber mood while too many lively decorations may distract from playing the game altogether. Additionally, having other activities available is handy—from board games to karaoke machines—as these can help fill down times during intermissions when needed.

With careful consideration given to setting up an engaging scene and providing inventive refreshments, parties are sure to be ones that attendees won’t soon forget; just make sure not get so caught up in crafting an exciting scene that you forget what this event is all about—solving a murder mystery!

Next, we'll delve into how to host and play a successful murder mystery game.

Hosting and Playing the Game

Hosting a murder mystery game is an entertaining, interactive way to keep everyone engaged and provide them with a night of fun. For small groups, it is important for the host to both create and facilitate the activities. Here are a few tips to help you host a successful murder mystery game:

First, it is important to pick the theme for the game. Choose something that will allow your guests to get into character and have fun. If you’re having difficulty deciding, consider popular themes like a 1920s speakeasy or Sherlock Holmes-inspired case.

Next, create game sheets for all of your guests. Include information about their characters as well as any riddles or clues they need to be successful in solving the mystery. Be sure to mix up the character traits so each guest has a unique storyline.

Finally, plan out what activities and conversations need to take place during the party in order to make progress on the case. Remember, when players are overly focused on the game itself they can miss out on plenty of engaging conversation opportunities which might help solve the mystery quicker!

Playing a murder mystery game is also no small feat! Everyone needs to keep their eye open for subtle hints and details throughout the evening that may help reveal who was behind the crime. Here are a few tips for players:

First, get lost in your character and remember each detail by creating an internal story line for yourself if necessary. Even little details like what kind of shoes your character wears can help your clues start coming together.

Second, don’t be afraid to talk with other players about what their individual stories are. You never know which tiny piece of information might unlock a bigger part of the case!

Finally, don’t shy away from asking questions (in character!) even if they seem silly – especially if it's something you feel your character would ask in an attempt to solve the case faster!

Remember - playing a murder mystery game is supposed to be fun! With all these tips in mind you’ll be well on your way towards hosting an entertaining evening amongst friends that will have everyone talking long after everything is said and done. Up next: releasing clues and giving riddles--two integral parts of any great murder mystery party!

Release the Clues and Riddles

Releasing the clues and riddles that are associated with hosting a murder mystery party are integral to creating an engaging experience for your small group. These elements will allow your players to gain insight into each character's motivations, secrets and roles in the case. It's important to have a large number of clues so that players are encouraged to explore various paths of investigation. As the facilitator, you will need to strategically convey these clues during conversations between characters, through mail correspondence, or available items in the game space.

It is also suggested that you design your own series of puzzles and riddles related to the storyline of your murder mystery. Incorporating these elements adds another layer of challenge and intrigue for your players as they search for vital information about the case. However, if designing puzzles can add a lot of pressure for people who might not have the time or are not comfortable doing so. In this case, there are plenty of resources available online where pre-made clues and puzzles can be purchased for use in one’s own party.

No matter how it is done, releasing these clues and riddles thoughtfully and carefully throughout the night will make sure players remain engaged as they explore all avenues related to solving the mystery.

The next step in planning a successful murder mystery party is ensuring you have all of the materials and supplies necessary for the night.

  • According to a 2019 survey, murder mystery board games are among the most popular in the United States, with over 50% of respondents indicating interest.
  • Data from Google Trends indicates that searches for murder mystery party games increase significantly around Halloween.
  • A study published in 2016 revealed that people were more likely to be completely engaged and attentive during murder mystery game play compared to other forms of social gaming.

Materials and Supplies Needed

Hosting a murder mystery party can be incredibly fun and exciting, especially for small groups. Before the game gets started, however, there are several materials and supplies that will need to be gathered in order to ensure a top-notch experience.

The bare minimum that one requires to host a successful murder mystery party are a script with predetermined roles, detective kit (a magnifying glass or similar item), costume options for each character, clues laid throughout the room, pens/pencils and paper for notes, and props related to the story. Depending on the size of the event (10-20 people is considered optimal) and the themes available, different supplies may be required to make each character come to life.

Additionally, it’s useful to have some games ready in case guests need a break from sleuthing. Card decks, board games and classic party appetizers like chips and dip all help keep spirits high while actors take turns developing their characters and delivering lines. These materials can also be used as rewards at the end of the game — any guest who correctly solves the mystery can win a prize like a gift card or candy bar.

At first glance, it may seem like quite a bit to collect for one event; however, many of these items can be found from home or borrowed from friends. Online stores offer pre-packaged themed sets with all necessary supplies included for an affordable price; this could help streamline preparation for those hosting their very first mystery party.

Now that we’ve gone over essential materials and supplies needed to properly host a murder mystery party, let's look next at alternatives to a traditional murder mystery game.

Alternatives to a Traditional Murder Mystery Game

Although a traditional murder mystery game is exciting and fun, there are several other alternatives available for small groups wanting to host their own mystery night. Assuming budgets permit, alternate mysteries might take the shape of escape rooms or live-action murder mystery tours, both of which can be booked by party planners for an extra cost. Escape rooms offer the challenge of solving puzzles with a wide variety of materials and themes, from the paranormal to historical trivia. Depending on the individual group's interests, a custom game may also be possible. Simulation games with clues hidden in scenic locations are another option; these offer the combined benefit of fast-paced action and being outdoors at the same time.

These types of activities might not be suitable for every crowd or age range; some people may also have physical restrictions which limit their ability to participate in certain activities. Handheld devices such as mobile phones and tablets can help supplement a traditional murder mystery game or provide an alternative activity if groups decide they want a change from traditional forms of party entertainment. These activities might include codes or digital puzzles that require obscure knowledge or problem-solving skills, like virtual scavenger hunts or riddles that reward clues when solved correctly.

No matter what path you choose for your mystery night, ensure that all participants understand any required rules and/or limitations before beginning so everyone has ample chance to enjoy the experience. As with any party game night, aim to create a balanced group atmosphere with an appropriate level of difficulty—not too easy and not too hard—for maximum enjoyment from all participants. Now we will move on to our conclusion and final thoughts section...

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Hosting a murder mystery party is an entertaining and creative way to get your small group of friends together for an evening of fun. It involves coming up with interesting characters and stories, presenting clues and asking questions to figure out who did it. At the end of the night, participants should be able to guess who the murderer was.

Organizing a murder mystery party can require some creativity and effort, but it’s well worth it when you see how much fun everyone has. Keep in mind that it’s important for all participants to be on the same page with game instructions and story lines. Make sure to provide plenty of clues for amateur sleuths who may not come up with the answer as quickly as others.

While hosting a murder mystery can be a lot of fun, some may argue that it's more trouble than its worth. If you lack the time or energy to do everything yourself, there are premade games available that provide players with everything they need to solve the case. The choice of whether you think this particular activity is right for your small group really depends on individual preferences. Either way, though, it will provide plenty of entertainment during your next gathering with friends!

Common Questions and Responses

How much time and preparation is required for murder mystery games?

The amount of time and preparation required for murder mystery games depends on several factors, such as the size of the group, the complexity of the game, and the level of creativity desired. Generally speaking, if you’re planning a more basic game with fewer characters and items to account for, the process could take only a few hours to prepare. However, if you are looking to add some unique components like custom-made clue cards or props, you will likely need to dedicate more time to research and execution. As with any gathering, it is important to make sure you have enough time beforehand to properly plan out your mystery game so that everything runs as smoothly as possible once it’s underway.

What are the most popular themes for murder mystery games?

The most popular themes for murder mystery games tend to be genres like crime and detective fiction or classic whodunnits. Popular themes can range from vintage noir to modern-day thrillers, secret agents to private eyes. Some of the most intriguing mysteries can involve supernatural elements like ghosts or zombies, technology gone wrong or supernatural powers clashing. No matter the theme, these games can be designed to provide suspenseful and entertaining evenings for your small group.

What is the recommended number of players for murder mystery games?

The recommended number of players for a murder mystery game depends on the type of game you're playing. Generally, anything larger than 12 can be difficult for players to keep track of. For traditional murder mystery party games where all guests form teams, it is best to have a minimum of six and a maximum of twelve players. If fewer than six people are playing, the group may lack diversity in backgrounds and characters. If more than twelve people are playing it can become quite chaotic as it can be hard to remember all of the details. Additionally, if there are too many people participating it might take too long to reach a resolution.

Related Content

Checkout our other guides for murder mystery games for large groups:

Play online or in real life murder mystery game

Play at a whodunnit dinner party with friends – or on Zoom, Facetime or Hangouts.


Murder Mystery Dinner Party

Host a murder mystery party your friends will love


Family Get-together

Nothing unites a family like murder!


Play over video

Play online or in real life

Create your personalized murder mystery game

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly to your phone
  • Play online or in-person
Make My Murder Mystery Game

“It was so much fun and easy for people to get involved. A really brilliant murder mystery story!”

Nick T

“Everyone was engaged from the start and threw themselves into solving the murder. The event was great fun – and brilliant value for money.”

Bryn J

“Hilarious! Played over Zoom, in 6 locations, including 2 countries. Even our 78 year old mother managed it!”

Joseph H

“A great night with friends! Will definitely be going with these guys again!”

Tori K

Play online or in-person

Play on Zoom or get together in real life

Create your own murder mystery

Customize your game script

Quick and simple to build

Only takes 15 mins to create

Add your own characters

Use real names or make them up

Play on your phone

Or print out the PDF script

Fun for everyone

Detectives aged 11+

Whodunnit game night

A murder mystery game to play with friends

Crime solving game

Use your detective skills

Create your personalized murder mystery game

  • Create a customised murder mystery script in less than 15 mins
  • Perfect for dinner parties and virtual team building
  • Play on screens or print out the PDF scripts
Make My Murder Mystery Game

Create a personalized murder mystery game

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly to your phone
  • Play online or in real life
Build My Personalized Murder Mystery Game