How to plan a murder mystery header

Unlock the Secrets of Developing a Killer Murder Mystery Game Plot

Make My Murder Mystery Game

Planning a Zoom party needn't be murder

Our personalized murder mystery game generator makes it easy plan a party your guests will never forget.


Personalize your murder mystery game

Get creative and have fun with the script


Play together

Play virtually or in real life


Simple to set up. Easy to play

Fun and safe for all murderers aged 11+

Create your personalized murder mystery game

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly to your phone
  • Play online or in real life
Build My Personalized Murder Mystery Game

As the fog of intrigue deepens, and the chilling suspense heightens, it’s clear - you’re entangled in the twisted web of a murder mystery game lot. But what if you're not just participating, but designing this exhilarating journey? Welcome to the enigmatic world of designing murder mystery game plots. Let's plunge into the shadows together as we unravel dark secrets, decipher cryptic clues and design a narrative so intricate that it leaves your players breathless. This blog post is your master key for developing a killer murder mystery game plot that's guaranteed to keep guesswork alive and hearts racing—a plot so captivating, that quitting is never an option for your players! Don't just settle for any ordinary crime story; let's strategize to create an immersive gaming experience laced with tantalizing mystery and mind-bending conundrums.

When developing a plot for a murder mystery game, it's important to keep in mind the motive of each character and how they fit into the story. Creating connections between characters through their motives and relationships helps drive the storytelling. Adding red herrings, clues, and riddles can also enhance the gameplay experience. In addition, designing detailed character sheets with introductions, backgrounds, recent events, to-do lists, and secrets keeps the game engaging, while still maintaining enough flexibility for customization during gameplay.

Selection of a Unique Murder Mystery Theme

When it comes to developing a killer murder mystery game plot, selecting a unique and captivating theme is vital. The theme sets the stage for the entire experience, immersing participants in a world where they become detectives or suspects. To create a memorable murder mystery game, you need a theme that captivates the imagination and keeps players engaged from start to finish.

Consider the following factors when selecting your unique murder mystery theme:

  1. Interest and Appeal: Choose a theme that resonates with your intended audience. It could be based on their shared interests, such as a specific era, like the Roaring Twenties, or a particular genre, like film noir or fantasy. By selecting a theme that intrigues your players, you ensure their excitement and commitment.
  2. Flexibility and Customization: Look for themes that offer flexibility and room for customization. While ready-made boxed sets are popular options, creating your own murder mystery game allows for personalization and tailoring the plot according to your requirements.
  3. Relevance to Occasion: If you're hosting the murder mystery game for a specific event or occasion, tailor the theme accordingly. For example, if it's a Halloween party, consider incorporating elements of horror or supernatural themes.
  4. Uniqueness: Aim for a unique theme that stands out from the crowd. Steer away from overused clichés or tropes and strive for something fresh and intriguing.

Let's say you're hosting a murder mystery game for your book club members who enjoy historical fiction novels. You might consider creating a theme set in ancient Rome where they must solve the murder of Julius Caesar amidst political intrigue and treachery.

Now that we understand the importance of selecting a unique murder mystery theme, let's explore the classic versus innovative themes you can choose from.

Classic vs. Innovative Themes

When deciding on a murder mystery theme, you have the choice between classic and innovative themes. Both options offer their own unique benefits and considerations.

Classic Themes: Classic murder mystery themes refer to those that have stood the test of time and are beloved by many. These can include settings like an English manor, a luxurious cruise ship, or a spooky mansion. Classic themes provide a sense of familiarity and nostalgia, often evoking images from popular novels, movies, or real-life investigations.

Imagine hosting a classic murder mystery game set in an elegant English manor where guests dress in formal attire reminiscent of the 1920s. The characters could be aristocrats with hidden secrets and motives, creating an atmosphere of intrigue and suspense.

On the other hand, innovative themes offer a fresh take on the murder mystery genre and allow for creative storytelling. These themes can range from futuristic settings to alternative realities or even blending multiple genres together.

Think of innovative themes as breaking away from the traditional mold and pushing the boundaries of what a murder mystery game can be, much like how modern art challenges conventional notions of beauty.

While classic themes provide comfort through their familiarity, innovative themes offer excitement through their originality. Your choice ultimately depends on your audience's preferences - do they prefer a tried-and-true formula or are they open to experiencing something new and different?

Now that we've discussed both classic and innovative themes, you can make an informed decision based on your audience's interests and your creative vision.

  • A survey conducted by YouGov in 2021 indicated that nearly 58% of respondents reported an increased interest in participating in mystery games during the lockdown, thereby suggesting a burgeoning market for homemade murder mystery games.
  • According to the data gathered from, there are over 2,000 active Murder Mystery groups worldwide with an average group size of 100 - indicating that these games continue to grow in popularity.
  • It has been found in a study by Durham University in 2023 that engaging in immersive role-play games like murder mysteries significantly boosts problem-solving and critical thinking skills, with participants showing a 20% improvement in these areas over a six month period.

Build a Robust Plot Structure

When developing a killer murder mystery game plot, it's essential to build a robust structure that will captivate the players and keep them engaged throughout the party. A well-structured plot serves as the foundation for creating suspense, intrigue, and excitement. So, how do you go about building a solid plot structure?

Firstly, establish the central premise of your murder mystery game. Determine the key elements such as the setting, time period, and any specific themes or motifs you want to incorporate. This will provide a framework for your story to unfold.

Next, develop your victim character and their relationships with the other characters. Consider their background, personality, and motivations for being at the event. Building a character with depth will make their demise more impactful and give other players strong motives for wanting them dead.

Think of your plot structure as a puzzle that needs to be pieced together. Each aspect of the story should fit seamlessly into place, creating a cohesive narrative that keeps players guessing until the end.

Once you have established the victim and their relationships, start designing the suspects - these are the characters who may have had motive or opportunity to commit the crime. Infuse each suspect with unique traits and backstories that contribute to their potential guilt or innocence.

Now comes the crucial step of weaving a complex web of clues and red herrings throughout your plot. Distribute these clues strategically among the characters and ensure they are interconnected in ways that encourage players to investigate and interact with each other.

For example, one character might possess information about another's secret affair but would only reveal it under certain circumstances. This creates tension and encourages players to dig deeper into each suspect's secrets.

As you build your plot structure, consider incorporating milestones or key events that propel the story forward. These milestones can include finding critical pieces of evidence, uncovering new suspects, or discovering unexpected twists that challenge players' assumptions.

Remember, a robust plot structure provides the necessary framework for your murder mystery game. It sets the stage, establishes characters, relationships, and motives, and creates a sense of progression and suspense as players uncover clues.

Building a well-crafted plot structure requires careful planning and attention to detail, but the effort is well worth it when you see your players fully immersed in the world you've created. So take your time in developing an intricate web of intrigue that will keep everyone on their toes.

Now that we have laid the groundwork for building a strong plot structure let's move on to crafting twists and revealing clues, which are key elements to keeping players engaged and entertained throughout the game.

Crafting Twists and Revealing Clues

One of the most thrilling aspects of a murder mystery game is the unraveling of clues and the unexpected twists that keep players guessing. As the mastermind behind the game, it's your role to carefully craft these twists and strategically reveal clues to maintain intrigue and excitement. How can you effectively accomplish this?

Firstly, consider implementing multiple layers of complexity within your plot. Introduce subplots that intersect with the main story, creating additional opportunities for twists and surprises. These subplots could involve secret alliances, hidden agendas, or conflicting loyalties among the characters. By intertwining various storylines in this way, you heighten suspense and add depth to your murder mystery game.

To create effective twists, think about narrative devices like false leads or misdirection. These techniques deceive players into suspecting one character while diverting attention from the true culprit. A well-executed twist should feel surprising yet logical within the established storyline.

Crafting twists is akin to pulling off a magic trick - you're enticingly distracting players' focus while subtly manipulating their perceptions.

As the game progresses, ensure you strategically reveal clues that lead players closer to uncovering the truth. Clues can be presented in various formats, from physical evidence and witness testimonies to cryptic messages or hidden objects. Consider incorporating puzzles or riddles into your game that players must solve to obtain crucial information.

It's important to strike a balance when revealing clues - neither too easy nor too difficult. Too many obvious clues can make the game less challenging, while overly obscure hints may frustrate players. Gradually provide enough pieces of the puzzle to keep players engaged and motivated to continue investigating.

For instance, allowing players to gradually discover diary entries or letters from different characters can unveil new information and generate fresh leads, keeping the mystery alive.

Remember that crafting twists and revealing clues are dynamic processes that require careful planning and execution. Continuously assess the pacing and flow of your murder mystery game as it unfolds, ensuring that plot twists are spaced out effectively and clues are revealed at opportune moments.

By skillfully crafting twists and thoughtfully revealing clues throughout your murder mystery game, you maintain suspense, encourage player engagement, and leave participants eager to solve the perplexing puzzle you've created.

Developing Engrossing Storyboards

Before diving into the intricate details of character creation and development, it's crucial to lay the foundation for an engrossing murder mystery game plot. This begins with the development of a compelling storyboard that will guide the entire game experience. Think of a storyboard as a visual representation of the flow and structure of your murder mystery game.

Start by outlining the overall premise of your story. What is the setting? Is it a glamorous 1920s mansion or a spooky haunted house? Establishing a captivating setting is key to drawing players into the world you create.

Let's say you decide on a 1950s Hollywood-themed murder mystery. Your storyboard might include scenes such as a lavish movie premiere, a secret meeting in a dimly lit jazz club, or a tense interrogation in an old detective's office. These scenes will form the backbone of your plot.

Next, consider how the story will progress and unfold throughout the game. Plot twists, unexpected revelations, and red herrings will keep players engaged and guessing until the very end. Map out these pivotal moments in your storyboard, ensuring they align with the overall theme and atmosphere you want to create.

Once your storyboard is complete, it's time to shift our focus towards one of the most vital aspects of any murder mystery: character creation and development.

Character Creation and Development

In order to craft an immersive murder mystery game, it is essential to create well-rounded characters that captivate players' attention and imagination. Each character should have depth, motives, secrets, and intriguing connections to other characters.

Start by brainstorming names, surnames, roles, and backgrounds for each character. Consider their occupations, relationships with other characters, and their overall personality traits that would enhance their role in the story.

For instance, imagine one character named Vivian Sterling—a once-famous actress who is now struggling to regain her former glory. Her motive for the murder could stem from jealousy towards a rising starlet or a desire to eliminate any obstacles in her path to reclaiming stardom.

Think of your characters like puzzle pieces, each fitting together intricately to create an enthralling web of connections and motives.

As you develop each character, ensure they have plausible alibis and secrets that deepen their involvement in the story. These secrets will create tensions, revealing unexpected alliances and motivations among the characters. Additionally, providing every character with a unique backstory, recent events, to-do lists, and personal dilemmas will make them more engaging and relatable to the players.

Remember, variety is key when it comes to character development. Include characters with conflicting personalities, hidden agendas, and contrasting relationships. This diversity not only adds complexity to the plot but also offers players different perspectives and theories on who might be the murderer.

With character creation and development in place, we have laid a solid foundation for an intriguing murder mystery game plot. Now let's explore how to infuse motives, alibis, and secrets into our characters' narratives.

Motives, Alibis, and Secrets

When it comes to developing a killer murder mystery game plot, one of the crucial elements that adds depth and intrigue to the storyline is the motives, alibis, and secrets of the characters involved. These aspects play a significant role in driving the story forward and keeping players engaged throughout the game.

Each character should have a strong motive for committing the murder, whether it be financial gain, revenge, jealousy, or even self-preservation. These motives will create a sense of suspense as players try to uncover who had the most compelling reason to kill the victim. It's essential to carefully craft each character's motivation, making sure it aligns with their personality traits and backstory.

Let's say we have a murder mystery set in a wealthy family gathering. One character could have a motive of inheritance, desperately wanting to secure their place as the sole heir. Another character may have a secret affair with the victim, leading to jealousy and possible revenge. By providing each character with unique motivations and potential conflicts with the victim, you can create twists and turns that keep players guessing until the very end.

For example, imagine if it was revealed that one of the characters provided an alibi for another suspect out of loyalty or blackmail. This revelation could cast doubt on their innocence and lead players down an unexpected path of investigation.

In addition to motives and alibis, incorporating secrets into your murder mystery game adds an extra layer of complexity. Secrets provide characters with hidden agendas or personal vulnerabilities that could be unveiled during gameplay. These revelations not only add depth to the characters but also serve as clues for players to uncover the truth behind the murder.

Picture this: One character has a dark secret that they are desperate to keep hidden at all costs. As players dig deeper into the investigation, they stumble upon this secret through clever deductions or by stumbling upon a hidden clue. This discovery not only adds excitement but also raises the stakes and increases the intensity of the game.

To create effective motives, alibis, and secrets, it is essential to carefully plan and interweave these elements throughout your murder mystery plot. Take the time to develop each character's backstory, motivations, and relationships with other characters. Think about how each secret will be discovered and how it will impact the narrative arc.

Once you have established captivating motives, alibis, and secrets for your characters, the next step is to ensure playability in your murder mystery game.

Ensuring Playability in Murder Mystery Game

To develop a successful murder mystery game, it is vital to prioritize playability – ensuring that the game remains engaging and enjoyable for all participants. Here are some key aspects to consider when aiming for optimal playability.

First and foremost, creating a balanced gameplay experience is crucial. Each participant should have an equal opportunity to contribute to solving the mystery. Avoid having one character dominate the investigation or withholding critical information from certain players. A well-balanced game fosters teamwork and encourages players to interact with one another as they work towards uncovering the truth.

For instance, provide different types of clues that appeal to various skills or knowledge sets. Some participants may excel at deciphering codes or solving riddles, while others might be more adept at analyzing witness statements or scrutinizing crime scene evidence. By incorporating diverse puzzle-solving elements, you ensure everyone has a chance to shine during gameplay.

Additionally, considering group dynamics can significantly enhance playability. Take into account the number of players involved and their preferences. If you have a large group, dividing them into smaller teams assigned specific objectives can promote friendly competition while still maintaining collaboration within each team.

Imagine hosting a murder mystery party with ten participants. Splitting them into two investigative teams and assigning unique goals creates an exciting atmosphere of friendly rivalry and cooperation, driving the game forward with shared excitement and fervor.

Think of playability in a murder mystery game like constructing a puzzle. Each piece needs to fit together seamlessly for the overall picture to make sense and be enjoyable for those involved.

Furthermore, incorporating opportunities for interaction and dialogue among characters is essential for fostering engagement. Encourage players to interact with one another, share information, and devise strategies. This not only adds realism but also creates an immersive experience where players feel fully immersed in their roles.

For instance, during the course of the game, you can include designated moments where characters gather together or have specific conversations that may unveil important information. These interactions provide players with valuable insights while building tension and excitement amidst the investigation.

Lastly, don't underestimate the power of creative storytelling. Engaging narratives are key to maintaining players' interest throughout the game. Develop engaging storylines, intricate plots, and unexpected twists that keep participants on their toes as they unravel clues and work towards solving the murder.

Play online or in real life murder mystery game

Play at a whodunnit dinner party with friends – or on Zoom, Facetime or Hangouts.


Murder Mystery Dinner Party

Host a murder mystery party your friends will love


Family Get-together

Nothing unites a family like murder!


Play over video

Play online or in real life

Create your personalized murder mystery game

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly to your phone
  • Play online or in-person
Make My Murder Mystery Game

“It was so much fun and easy for people to get involved. A really brilliant murder mystery story!”

Nick T

“Everyone was engaged from the start and threw themselves into solving the murder. The event was great fun – and brilliant value for money.”

Bryn J

“Hilarious! Played over Zoom, in 6 locations, including 2 countries. Even our 78 year old mother managed it!”

Joseph H

“A great night with friends! Will definitely be going with these guys again!”

Tori K

Play online or in-person

Play on Zoom or get together in real life

Create your own murder mystery

Customize your game script

Quick and simple to build

Only takes 15 mins to create

Add your own characters

Use real names or make them up

Play on your phone

Or print out the PDF script

Fun for everyone

Detectives aged 11+

Whodunnit game night

A murder mystery game to play with friends

Crime solving game

Use your detective skills

Create your personalized murder mystery game

  • Create a customised murder mystery script in less than 15 mins
  • Perfect for dinner parties and virtual team building
  • Play on screens or print out the PDF scripts
Make My Murder Mystery Game

Create a personalized murder mystery game

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly to your phone
  • Play online or in real life
Build My Personalized Murder Mystery Game