How to plan a murder mystery header

Make Your Halloween Murder Mystery Even More Fun With These Prize Ideas

Make My Murder Mystery Game

Planning a Zoom party needn't be murder

Our personalized murder mystery game generator makes it easy plan a party your guests will never forget.


Personalize your murder mystery game

Get creative and have fun with the script


Play together

Play virtually or in real life


Simple to set up. Easy to play

Fun and safe for all murderers aged 11+

Create your personalized murder mystery game

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly to your phone
  • Play online or in real life
Build My Personalized Murder Mystery Game

Unveil the spine-chilling anticipation of Halloween this year! Let's not just bob for apples - turn up the eerie essence with a thrilling Murder Mystery theme. Get your guests to outstare, outthink, and outlast each other for that ultimate victory. Intriguing, isn't it? Now imagine their zeal reaching sky-high when a sensational prize awaits the craftiest detective among them. Dive into this blog post to discover tantalizing prize ideas that are sure to send shivers down your guest's spines - in the best way possible! Every secret sleuth will be vying to crack the code first and take home the bone-chilling bounty.

Some good prize ideas for a Halloween Murder Mystery party include alcohol prizes, paper certificates, sweets or chocolate, themed goody bags, theme-related knick-knacks, detective equipment, online gift certificates, and Murder Mystery Game gift cards. When selecting prizes, it's important to consider the theme of the party and the interests of your guests. Be creative and tailor your prizes to fit the occasion!

Creative Prize Ideas for Halloween Murder Mystery

Adding an exciting element of competition to your Halloween murder mystery party can make the event even more thrilling. Offering creative and enticing prizes is a fantastic way to motivate your guests and enhance their overall experience. Here are some prize ideas that will leave your participants eager to solve the crime and win big:

Just like a treasure chest filled with goodies, these prizes create an atmosphere of anticipation and excitement, ensuring that everyone is fully engaged in the murder mystery game.

  1. Themed Gifts: Stay true to the Halloween theme by offering prizes that reflect the spooky ambiance. Consider gifting items like haunted house decor, witchy accessories, or vampire-inspired trinkets. These themed gifts not only serve as memorable keepsakes but also add an extra layer of fun to the event.
  2. Certificates: Awarding personalized certificates is a great way to recognize and appreciate the efforts of your participants. Create categories such as "Best Detective," "Most Convincing Performer," "Master of Disguise," or "Best Clue Interpreter." The recipients will feel proud of their accomplishments and cherish these certificates as mementos from the evening.
  3. Experiences: Take your prize-giving to the next level by offering unforgettable experiences related to the Halloween murder mystery theme. This could include escape room vouchers, tickets to immersive theatrical performances, or even a murder mystery-themed getaway. Providing experiential prizes adds an element of adventure and anticipation beyond the party itself.
  4. Personalized Mystery Novels: Delight your guests with a personalized mystery novel, where they become the lead detective solving a thrilling case. These custom-made novels can feature their names and incorporate details from the Halloween murder mystery party they attended. It's a unique and thoughtful prize that allows them to continue their detective journey long after the event.
  5. Detective Kits: Enhance the detective experience by awarding winners with complete detective kits. These can include magnifying glasses, fingerprint dusting kits, crime scene tape, and other tools of the trade. The recipients can then use these kits to solve mysteries or immerse themselves in detective role-play at home.
  6. Escape Room Vouchers: Further engage your guests' love for intrigue and problem-solving by offering vouchers for local escape rooms. This prize allows them to continue testing their skills as they navigate immersive puzzles and themed rooms, extending the excitement beyond the Halloween murder mystery party.

Now that we've explored some creative prize ideas, let's dive into another essential aspect of rewarding participants at a Halloween murder mystery party: enticing awards for character roles.

  • Adding a competitive element to a Halloween murder mystery party through creative and themed prize offerings can enhance the overall experience for guests. Personalized certificates, experiences related to the theme, detective kits, escape room vouchers, and personalized mystery novels are some of the exciting prize ideas that can motivate participants to solve the crime and win big. Additionally, awarding enticing awards for character roles is another significant aspect that can help recognize and appreciate each participant's efforts during the event.

Enticing Awards for Character Roles

One of the most exciting aspects of a Halloween murder mystery party is the opportunity for guests to take on unique character roles. These roles allow them to fully embody their assigned personalities, adding depth and intrigue to the gameplay. Recognizing and rewarding their efforts through enticing awards can elevate their experience even more.

Imagine the joy on a guest's face when they receive an award for their exceptional portrayal of a deceitful villain or a skilled detective who cracked the case wide open.

Here are some suggestions for enticing awards that will make your guests feel appreciated for their commitment to their character roles:

  1. Best Actor/Actress Award: Recognize outstanding performances by presenting an award for the best actor or actress of the evening. This prize acknowledges those who embodied their character with flair and authenticity, captivating others with their portrayal.
  2. Most Deceitful Villain Award: In any murder mystery game, there's always a cunning villain hiding amidst the suspects. Acknowledge their ability to deceive and manipulate others by presenting them with this coveted award. It adds an exciting twist to the experience as everyone tries to unravel who amongst them is truly untrustworthy.
  3. Super Sleuth Award: This award celebrates the participant who demonstrated brilliant detective skills, going above and beyond to solve the mystery. Whether it was their keen observation, deductive reasoning, or exceptional attention to detail, this prize recognizes their exceptional sleuthing abilities.
  4. Most Charismatic Character Award: Some participants have a natural talent for captivating others with their charisma and charm. Acknowledge their ability to engage and entertain by presenting them with this award. It highlights their outstanding social skills and their knack for making the murder mystery party even more enjoyable.
  5. Best Dressed Award: Encourage your guests to put on their most impressive costumes by offering a prize for the best-dressed character. This award celebrates creativity, originality, and attention to detail in costume selection and presentation.

Remember to consider the personalities of your guests when assigning awards for character roles. Tailor the categories to suit your specific event and participants, ensuring that everyone has a chance to shine.

Just like in an awards show where actors are recognized for their exceptional performances, these enticing awards add an element of prestige and excitement to the Halloween murder mystery party.

Unforgettable Experiences as Prizes

When it comes to adding an extra layer of excitement and anticipation to your Halloween murder mystery party, offering unforgettable experiences as prizes can take the festivities to a whole new level. Instead of traditional physical rewards, consider giving winners the opportunity to embark on unique adventures or enjoy special treats that they'll remember for years to come.

For instance, you could offer a weekend getaway to a spooky haunted house or a ghost tour in a historical town known for its supernatural stories. Imagine the thrill your guests will experience as they immerse themselves in the eerie atmosphere while solving mysteries during their own real-life adventure.

Another idea is to provide an escape room experience specifically designed around the murder mystery theme of your party. This way, the winners can continue their sleuthing skills with friends or family, testing their wits in a challenging environment.

If you're looking for options that cater to different preferences, consider offering vouchers for themed dinners at mysterious restaurants or tickets to interactive theater performances where audiences play detective alongside professional actors. These experiences allow winners to step into thrilling narratives and fully engage with their passion for mystery-solving.

Now that we've explored the concept of unforgettable experiences as prizes, let's turn our attention to another exciting category: novelty prizes for the best costume.

  • While no specific statistical data is available on ideal prizes for a Halloween Murder Mystery Party, research from Eventbrite suggests that 71% of event organizers find giving away themed items increases audience engagement.
  • According to Psychology Today, competitive activities such as games or contests during events increase enjoyment and participation by up to 63%.
  • A 2020 survey by MeetingsNet reveals that 78% of attendees felt more engaged in an event when there was a chance of earning fun and unique rewards or prizes.

Novelty Prizes for Best Costume

A Halloween murder mystery party wouldn't be complete without incredible costumes that truly capture the essence of each character. To encourage creativity and add an element of competition, awarding novelty prizes for the best costume is a fantastic idea. Not only does it motivate guests to put extra effort into their attire, but it also adds an additional layer of fun and excitement to the event.

Consider providing unique and quirky prizes that align with the murder mystery theme. For example, you could have customized "Detective Kits" prepared as prize packages. These kits might include magnifying glasses, notepads, pens, and other detective-themed accessories that guests can use during the party. It's a fun and practical way to reward costume winners and keep them engaged throughout the game.

Another prize idea is to offer personalized mystery novels with the winning guest's name as the main character. This unique keepsake will serve as a reminder of their achievement and allow them to immerse themselves in another intriguing storyline long after the party is over.

Additionally, consider providing escape room vouchers for winners to enjoy immersive mystery adventures with friends or family. This prize not only recognizes their exceptional costume but also provides them with an opportunity to continue their detective journey beyond the Halloween party.

Remember, novelty prizes should reflect the effort and creativity put into crafting an extraordinary costume. By offering prizes that align with the murder mystery theme and cater to the interests of your guests, you'll make the evening even more thrilling and memorable for everyone involved.

How to Choose the Most Fitting Awards?

When it comes to hosting a Halloween murder mystery party, choosing the right awards can elevate the fun and excitement for your guests. The key is to select prizes that align with the theme of the party and reflect the achievements or qualities of the participants. Here are some tips to help you choose the most fitting awards:

  1. Consider the Theme: Take into account the overall theme of your murder mystery party. If you've chosen a pirate theme, for example, you could offer prizes like a personalized pirate treasure chest filled with themed goodies or a replica pirate ship model. Matching the prize to the theme adds an extra layer of excitement and immersion.
  2. Reflect Achievements: Think about the accomplishments or special qualities of each participant. Did someone solve a particularly challenging clue? Consider recognizing their detective skills with an award like "Master Mind Solver" or "Mystery Sherlock." By acknowledging individual achievements, you not only make them feel special but also encourage active participation and engagement.
  3. Get Creative: Don't be afraid to think outside the box when selecting awards. Look for unique and unexpected items that tie into your theme or add an element of surprise. For example, if you're hosting a vampire-themed murder mystery, you could present the "Bite Me Award" along with a bottle of red wine or vampire-themed chocolates.
  4. Mix it Up: Offer a variety of different types of awards to cater to different strengths and interests among your guests. This could include awards for best performance, best costume, most valuable player, best accent, or best themed dish (more on this in the next section). Having a range of categories ensures that everyone has a chance to win something and keeps the competition lively throughout the event.
  5. Consider Practicality: While novelty items can be exciting, it's also important to consider practicality when selecting awards. Choose prizes that are useful or meaningful to the recipients. This could be a gift certificate to a local restaurant, a spa day, or a customized trophy or plaque.

Remember, the goal is to make your guests feel appreciated and rewarded for their participation. By selecting awards that align with the theme, reflect achievements, and offer a mix of categories, you can ensure an unforgettable Halloween murder mystery party experience.

Special Prizes for the Best Detective

In any murder mystery party, the role of the detective is crucial. This person gathers clues, interrogates suspects, and ultimately solves the crime. Recognizing their dedication and sleuthing skills with special prizes adds an extra level of excitement to the event.

One idea for a special prize is a "Detective Kit" which includes items like a magnifying glass, notepad, pens, fingerprint dusting kit, and a detective-themed book or movie. This prize not only acknowledges the detective's efforts but also provides them with tools to continue unraveling mysteries in their own time.

Another option is to award the best detective with a personalized mystery novel featuring their name as the protagonist. This unique keepsake will serve as a reminder of their successful deduction skills long after the party has ended.

For those who enjoy immersive experiences, consider offering escape room vouchers as an exciting reward for their detective prowess. This prize allows them to indulge in another thrilling challenge where they can put their problem-solving abilities to the test.

Lastly, if you want to go all out in honoring the best detective, consider arranging a murder mystery-themed getaway as the ultimate prize. This could involve a trip to a destination known for its intriguing history or hosting an exclusive murder mystery weekend at a luxury hotel. Such an experience would leave a lasting impression on your esteemed detective and provide them with an unforgettable adventure.

By offering special prizes specifically tailored for the best detectives at your Halloween murder mystery party, you not only acknowledge their accomplishments but also motivate other participants to strive for excellence in their sleuthing skills.

Rewarding the Best Performer and Best Themed Dish

In order to add an extra layer of excitement and competition to your Halloween murder mystery party, consider rewarding the best performer and best themed dish. These awards not only encourage guests to fully embrace their characters and costumes but also contribute to the overall enjoyment of the event.

The best performer award can be given to the guest who truly embraces their character, bringing them to life with enthusiasm, wit, and charisma. This award recognizes the individual who goes above and beyond to immerse themselves in the role assigned to them. It could be someone who delivers an exceptional monologue, improvises with skillful humor, or displays impeccable acting throughout the evening. By acknowledging their outstanding performance, you are not only highlighting their talent but also inspiring others to fully embrace their characters and make the murder mystery experience even more immersive.

On the other hand, the best themed dish award celebrates culinary creativity and adds a delicious element to your Halloween murder mystery party. Encourage guests to prepare dishes that relate to the theme or characters of the murder mystery game. For example, if your theme revolves around pirates, guests could whip up dishes like "Scurvy Scampi" or "Jolly Roger Jambalaya." This award recognizes not only the taste and presentation of the dish but also how well it correlates with the overall theme of the event. By incorporating this prize category, you are fostering a sense of culinary adventure and encouraging guests to contribute creatively to the atmosphere.

Don't forget that these awards can be customized based on your specific murder mystery game theme. For instance, you can have a "Best Vampire Accent" or "Most Eerie Monster Character" award if your theme revolves around vampires or monsters. Tailoring the awards to match your chosen theme adds an extra layer of fun and excitement for all participants.

Awarding the best performer and best themed dish can be done through a voting system. Consider distributing voting forms or slips to each guest along with their character booklets at the beginning of the party. This allows everyone to have a say in who should win these coveted awards. Alternatively, you can appoint a small panel of judges who will carefully observe and evaluate each guest's performance and culinary creation throughout the evening.

Remember, it's not just about the prizes themselves, but also the recognition and appreciation shown to each individual's effort. Make sure to announce the winners during a designated part of the party, creating suspense and excitement as guests eagerly await the results.

Rewarding the best performer and best themed dish adds an extra layer of fun and competition to your Halloween murder mystery party. By recognizing and celebrating exceptional performances and creative culinary contributions, you are fostering an immersive experience for all participants. So, get ready to witness incredible acting skills and indulge in delectable themed dishes that will elevate your murder mystery event to new heights of enjoyment. Now, let's move on to explore more exciting prize ideas for your Halloween murder mystery party!

Play online or in real life murder mystery game

Play at a whodunnit dinner party with friends – or on Zoom, Facetime or Hangouts.


Murder Mystery Dinner Party

Host a murder mystery party your friends will love


Family Get-together

Nothing unites a family like murder!


Play over video

Play online or in real life

Create your personalized murder mystery game

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly to your phone
  • Play online or in-person
Make My Murder Mystery Game

“It was so much fun and easy for people to get involved. A really brilliant murder mystery story!”

Nick T

“Everyone was engaged from the start and threw themselves into solving the murder. The event was great fun – and brilliant value for money.”

Bryn J

“Hilarious! Played over Zoom, in 6 locations, including 2 countries. Even our 78 year old mother managed it!”

Joseph H

“A great night with friends! Will definitely be going with these guys again!”

Tori K

Play online or in-person

Play on Zoom or get together in real life

Create your own murder mystery

Customize your game script

Quick and simple to build

Only takes 15 mins to create

Add your own characters

Use real names or make them up

Play on your phone

Or print out the PDF script

Fun for everyone

Detectives aged 11+

Whodunnit game night

A murder mystery game to play with friends

Crime solving game

Use your detective skills

Create your personalized murder mystery game

  • Create a customised murder mystery script in less than 15 mins
  • Perfect for dinner parties and virtual team building
  • Play on screens or print out the PDF scripts
Make My Murder Mystery Game

Create a personalized murder mystery game

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly to your phone
  • Play online or in real life
Build My Personalized Murder Mystery Game