How to plan a murder mystery header

The Top 10 Best Rated Murder Mystery Games for a Thrilling Night In

Make My Murder Mystery Game

Planning a Zoom party needn't be murder

Our personalized murder mystery game generator makes it easy plan a party your guests will never forget.


Personalize your murder mystery game

Get creative and have fun with the script


Play together

Play virtually or in real life


Simple to set up. Easy to play

Fun and safe for all murderers aged 11+

Create your personalized murder mystery game

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly to your phone
  • Play online or in real life
Build My Personalized Murder Mystery Game

Gather up your dearest mates, shut out the entire world, and immerse yourselves in a thrilling game of murder mystery. There is nothing like having control over your own story and deducing who the murderer is before the designated suspect arrives. So, crack open a bottle of wine and sharpen up your wits. We have compiled the ultimate list that seeks to lead you to success and to an evening you will never forget.

Without further ado, here are the top 10 best rated murder mystery games that guarantee a thrilling night in.

Quick Explanation of Key Points

Clue and Mysterium are both highly rated murder mystery games. Other popular choices include Betrayal at House on the Hill and Letters from Whitechapel.

The Top 5 Best Murder Mystery Games

When it comes to the best murder mystery games, there are a few great options that consistently top the list. The top five best murder mystery games for a thrilling night in include:

1. Murder by Death – This cooperative game centres around classic detective fiction stories and encourages players to work together to investigate and solve cases. It’s customizable so that everyone can become their own master sleuth and make their case as difficult or as easy as they want.

2. Clue – One of the most recognisable board games out there, Clue is full of suspense, suspicion and daring possibilities. Players gather clues in a race to discover who committed the crime, what they used and where it was done–all while dodging competitors trying to do the same!

3. Exit – This series of escape room-style card games require players to work together to solve puzzles and find a way out within an allotted time frame. Players must use creative problem-solving skills to win—but failure leads to certain doom!

4. Detective Club – With no set rules or board setup, Detective Club is both accessible and practical for all ages. Players must rely on observation and deduction powers alone—no luck needed!—to assess multiple possible scenarios before uncovering the truth.

5. Mysterium – In this modern take on a traditional English parlour game, one player assumes the role of ghost while up to seven others are psychics trying to interpret visions given by the ghost pertaining to how someone was killed. It's hard work though: only one psychic can win!

No matter which game is chosen for your night in, these five murder mystery games are sure to provide plenty of thrills from start to finish. For those looking for an even more immersive gaming experience however, an award-winning interactive story may offer just that!

Key Summary Points

There are five great murder mystery games for a thrilling night in including Murder by Death, Clue, Exit, Detective Club, and Mysterium. These games provide plenty of suspense and require players to use their problem-solving and deductive reasoning skills in order to win. For an even more immersive experience, an interactive story may be considered.

Award-Winning Interactive Stories

The sixth spot in our countdown is reserved for the top award-winning interactive stories on the market. Not all murder mystery games are created equal – some are elegant, complex puzzles that take intense thought and logical deduction to solve, while others immerse players in an exciting world with compelling stories full of twists and turns. The games we've picked out for this category have been recognised for their achievements in storytelling, and offer an exciting experience each time you play them.

On one hand, some argue that traditional murder mystery games are good enough. But these award-winning stories elevate the genre to a new level, immersing you in a unique setting and engaging you with characters that feel real. By delving deeper into the motives behind each character’s actions, these tales provide a more nuanced interpretation of murder mysteries than simple puzzles can accomplish.

In addition to complex storylines, these titles also incorporate elements of role-playing and improvisation that can add another layer of fun to your experience. Players must shift their perspectives as they join different groups within the game to learn secrets that may be key to solving the crime. This extra dimension brings a refreshing challenge to classic whodunit mysteries.

These award-winning interactive stories wrap up outstanding plots typically found in movies and TV shows in an enjoyable game format – providing an engaging experience for both seasoned detectives and beginner sleuths alike. To top it off, when playing with family or friends, award-winning interactive story murder mystery games bring people together through conversation and collaboration as they work together to solve the crime at hand. As we move from exploring the best-rated murder mystery games to uncovering what makes them truly unique, one thing is certain – there’s never a dull moment when experiencing these tales of intrigue!

What Makes These Games So Unique?

These top 10 murder mystery games offer an unparallelled level of intricacy, challenge and gripping storylines that have been highly praised by both game-players and critics alike. From their award-winning interactive stories to their lush graphics, the best rated murder mystery games bring a high-level of realism and immersion to the gaming experience. What’s more, many of these games feature multiple narratives and characters, as well as branching pathways that can lead to entirely new outcomes when making decisions throughout the game. As such, you can be sure that every playthrough will be a new adventure every time!

The remarkably lifelike 3D visuals further enhance the captivating gameplay as you traverse various exotic locations including mansions, castles, fortresses and even steampunk towers. The authenticity doesn’t stop there either – soundtracks composed by some of the world’s most acclaimed composers add great depth to these immersive worlds, filling each scene with emotion and electrifying energy. Furthermore, you may even find yourself facing unpredictable traps and puzzles which you’ll have to solve in order to secure your safety in the game and make it out alive.

Whether you prefer co-operative or competitive gaming, these murder mystery games offer something for everyone. With so much going on all at once, they provide a unique upending of conventional gameplay which is sure to thrill each player thoroughly.

Now that we've explored the variety of features that make these games so unique, it's time to consider selecting amongst them. In the next section we will take a closer look at choosing just one game that's right for you - one where your decisions will prove crucial in determining how the night plays out!

Which Game is Right For You? Choose Wisely!

When it comes to deciding which murder mystery game is the right one for you and your group, there are a few things to consider. Intended difficulty level, whether you’re looking for flexibility in the number of players and duration of play, or even the complexity of the story line. Some games are designed with a single extended session while others may offer similarly themed individual puzzles or incorporate multiple roles and complexities so that everyone gets an opportunity to flex their sleuthing skills.

Depending on how serious you want your night of mystery to be, some games may include certain gag elements that can add a fun twist to the experience. Of course there are also the classic escape room style challenge games that can require significant amounts of strategic optimisation and problem-solving skills. Consider analysing each option and discussing with your group before making your choice so that everyone is fully engaged and enjoys the night.

Now that you’ve carefully considered which murder mystery game is best suited for your group time to decide what kind of puzzles and immersive story lines will best capture the atmosphere of mystery and suspense keeping everyone eagerly guessing until the end.

Puzzles and Immersive Story Lines

Puzzles and Immersive Story Lines are key components to the excitement, challenge and fun of a murder mystery game. For those who prefer more strategy and in-depth thinking, puzzles add an extra level of complexity to the game. Solving these puzzles can be difficult but highly rewarding when done correctly-- it’ll tickle your brain like no other activity! On the other hand, for players who prefer a more laid back experience, immersive story lines with twists and turns provide a thrilling journey that you can delve into at your own pace.

The debate between puzzles vs. immersive story lines is quite popular among gamers. There’s evidence that suggests both offer unique benefits that contribute to making the game enjoyable. For instance, the broad range of puzzles used in some games diversifies the challenges which can make it more exciting than games without this element. They also give players a great chance to test their problem-solving skills, which simply isn’t possible with more plot-based games. Conversely, an immersive story line helps draw people into a world they may have never visited before, gaining insight into what made the game so successful and beloved by many. Every detail matters in telling an engaging tale that captivates readers and creates wonderful memories.

Ultimately, both puzzles and immersive story lines bring something special to murder mystery games that results in hours of enjoyment and entertainment for players. Thus, it’s worth considering if either or both types best suit your interests when browsing through the top rated murder mystery games out there.

With the right game picked out, now it's time to look at the features of the game itself and how these pieces come together to create a cohesive yet thrilling gaming experience.

Fun and Interesting Game Play Features

Having discussed the thrilling puzzles and immersive story lines of some of the top rated murder mystery games, it is important to consider the fascinating game play features available in these titles. The majority of modern murder mystery games feature a variety of mini-games and tasks that offer an entertaining respite from traditional player-versus-environment (PVE) style gameplay. Many players enjoy this kind of innovative, fun game play as it takes them out of their comfort zone while still keeping them engaged in the narrative. However, some players may prefer more traditional PVE experiences that allow them to complete objectives with less distraction or random elements.

Ultimately, everyone has different preferences when it comes to game mechanics; however, there can be no question that murder mystery games featuring diverse and interesting game play offer a great opportunity for casual gamers to explore unique scenarios that evoke intrigue and suspense. Whether one chooses a more classic experience or decides to invest their energy into uncovering secrets via random events and mini-games in newer murder mystery titles is up to each individual's personal preference.

Taking a break from discussing puzzle elements and narrative discussion, one must now consider if they would prefer an online or offline murder mystery gaming environment – the next important factor to consider when exploring the best rated titles for a thrilling night in.

  • According to Steam, the best rated Murder Mystery game is PAYDAY 2, with an average rating of 91%.
  • Barring PAYDAY 2, there are six other games classified by Steam as Murder Mystery that have an average rating of 80% or higher.
  • According to research published by Newzoo in 2019, the global market for interactive entertainment (including video games and eSports) was estimated to be worth around $137.9 billion.

Online or Offline Murder Mystery Games

When it comes to murder mystery games, one of the most important decisions you will have to make is whether you want to play the game online or offline. In the past, traditional board games were the only option for those looking for a good murder mystery, but today’s technology has made it possible to play these thrilling games through the internet.

Online murder mystery games are immensely popular for several reasons. The biggest draw of playing an online game is that you can join other players from all around the world who share your interest in solving puzzles and crimes. Many online games also come with chat features, so even if none of your friends are playing the game with you, you can still interact with others and form teams or alliances while solving the case. You can usually save your progress in online games so that you don’t have to start over again whenever you take a break. Additionally, some online mystery games may include extra content like soundtracks and mini-games that will add depth and suspense to your experience.

On the other hand, many people still prefer the traditional board game approach when they go out searching for a good murder mystery. Board games allow players to be physically present as they go about solving the crime at hand, which can be a great way to bond with family and friends - something that is missing from virtual visits. Plus, many traditional board games come with intricate storylines and mind-boggling puzzles that require a lot of logical deduction before reaching your final conclusion. Playing these types of game in physical form makes them more interesting and engaging than the digital version could ever be.

Ultimately, deciding whether to play an online or offline murder mystery game will depend on what kind of experience you are looking for. Whether it's interacting with other people from across the world or gathering around a coffee table for an engaging mental challenge with family and friends – there's something for everyone in this classic genre of entertainment.

Answers to Frequently Asked Questions with Detailed Explanations

Are there any murder mystery games available for free?

Yes, there are some great free murder mystery games available for a thrilling night in. Many of them are simple yet effective and offer plenty of intrigue and challenge to your group. Some great free options include Crowdo's "The Grisly Murders of Boddy Mansion", "Murder By the Lake" from Adventurers Club, and "Death Comes Asking" from Nonsensical Games. All of these games offer suspenseful storylines with plenty of clues to solve the mystery. With low cost or no-cost options like these, you can have a wonderfully exciting night without breaking the bank.

How much do the best rated murder mystery games typically cost?

The cost of the best rated murder mystery games depends on various factors, including the number of players, length of game time, content of the game and the company producing it. Generally, the price ranges from around $15 for a basic boxed set to over $100 for a more interactive and immersive experience. Many companies offer subscription services that provide regular access to new content or story lines so you can continue your game night with friends or family members.

What criteria should I consider when selecting a murder mystery game?

When selecting a murder mystery game, it is important to consider several criteria. First, the difficulty level should match your party’s skill level. If some party members are novices, you will want an easier game so everyone can enjoy it. Second, the amount of time it takes to complete the game should also be taken into account. If you have limited time, opt for a game that can be completed in an hour or two. Third, think about how much writing and preparation is required before playing the game. If you want something more low-maintenance where most things are provided to you, games with ready-made characters, storyline suggestions, props and instructions might be best. Finally, make sure the theme and/or setting works for your group; some may prefer an interactive game that uses humour or pop culture references rather than a traditional one set in an old-fashioned manor house.

Play online or in real life murder mystery game

Play at a whodunnit dinner party with friends – or on Zoom, Facetime or Hangouts.


Murder Mystery Dinner Party

Host a murder mystery party your friends will love


Family Get-together

Nothing unites a family like murder!


Play over video

Play online or in real life

Create your personalized murder mystery game

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly to your phone
  • Play online or in-person
Make My Murder Mystery Game

“It was so much fun and easy for people to get involved. A really brilliant murder mystery story!”

Nick T

“Everyone was engaged from the start and threw themselves into solving the murder. The event was great fun – and brilliant value for money.”

Bryn J

“Hilarious! Played over Zoom, in 6 locations, including 2 countries. Even our 78 year old mother managed it!”

Joseph H

“A great night with friends! Will definitely be going with these guys again!”

Tori K

Play online or in-person

Play on Zoom or get together in real life

Create your own murder mystery

Customize your game script

Quick and simple to build

Only takes 15 mins to create

Add your own characters

Use real names or make them up

Play on your phone

Or print out the PDF script

Fun for everyone

Detectives aged 11+

Whodunnit game night

A murder mystery game to play with friends

Crime solving game

Use your detective skills

Create your personalized murder mystery game

  • Create a customised murder mystery script in less than 15 mins
  • Perfect for dinner parties and virtual team building
  • Play on screens or print out the PDF scripts
Make My Murder Mystery Game

Create a personalized murder mystery game

  • Create your game in less than 15 mins
  • Delivered instantly to your phone
  • Play online or in real life
Build My Personalized Murder Mystery Game